Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Alcohol is not an antidote! It only competes with enzyme binding to slow the production of fomic acid.

Fomepizole costs thousands of dollars and is often unstocked for that reason in many countries, although I guess it will become stocked in the US now. Dialysis machines are also in short supply. One mass poisoning event would overwhelm available dialysis resources in a state.

>>Bootleg brewers also sometimes add enough methanol to informally produced spirits to cause serious health effects.

> Again, as I said, someone intentionally trying to poison you.

No, someone in the supply chain making cash. Someone swapped in some 20% methanol and hoped it would go unnoticed.

You can cherry pick a study from Texas where there are hardcore home distillers, but that won't change what happens when a heap of amateurs across the country do it.

Eg Turkey https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11097313/

Also let's not ignore the toxic copper and lead in the moonshine. It is a persistent problem.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01960...

Obviously you are going to hold tight to your beliefs. Please spread them somewhere else.

 help



I didn't say antidote, I did say its used in treatment.

How do you imagine a mass poisoning event is going to occur? Is it something like a mass ecoli or salmonella event?

>No, someone in the supply chain making cash. Someone swapped in some 20% methanol and hoped it would go unnoticed.

How does that have anything to do with home made and unsold products?

You're raising a valid issue with any tainted consumable, not something specific to home distillation.

>Also let's not ignore the toxic copper and lead in the moonshine. It is a persistent problem.

You can, if you do what's common and build out of stainless steel. And again we're talking home consumption.

Why are you the police of what I poison myself with?

>Obviously you are going to hold tight to your beliefs. Please spread them somewhere else

I'm sticking with the data, you are angry and wrong. Your ignorance at this point is willful. GLWT.


> A 10% ethanol solution administered intravenously is a safe and effective antidote for severe methanol poisoning. Ethanol therapy is recommended when plasma methanol concentrations are higher than 20 mg per dl, when ingested doses are greater than 30 ml and when there is evidence of acidosis or visual abnormalities in cases of suspected methanol poisoning.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1306022/

So I their words, it is an antitode, effective and recommended treatment.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: