Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Math pedant to the rescue! Actually, rates combine in a multiplicative way -- losing 3% and then 4% does not lose 7%, (though it's close). What if the economy lost 1% each day for a year? It would not lose 365%.

If we assume the annualized rate, the economy would be 97.1% of its current size in a year. The fourth root is 99.267%, so the economy shrank about 0.733% this quarter. If it does so for four consecutive quarters, it will decrease by 2.9%.

I know that's what you said in the first place, but when extrapolating further into the future, it makes a difference.



Actually I didn't think about annualized rates compounding like that, although it makes sense now that you mention it :)


Math pedants of the world:

If you calculate 1-(1-x)^(1/4), the difference between the true answer and x/4 is approximately 3 * x^2/32. For a figure of y percent, this is a relative error of 0.375 * y percent. Ignore it when y is small.

The GDP figure is only known to something like 1 or 2 decimal places.


If I'm not mistaken, if you keep following that thread, somehow or other you eventually get e. I hope that wasn't too much pedantry.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: